top of page

Insights: Five Strategies for Managing Workplace Conflict

6 minutes ago
4 min read

Conflict is a natural part of working with other people. Differences in perspectives, competing priorities, miscommunication, and unmet expectations can all lead to tension in the workplace. While conflict is often uncomfortable, it can create opportunities for better communication, stronger working relationships, and more effective collaboration.


In Nonprofit Net's webinar, Conflict Resolution in the Workplace, presenters Anya McDavitt and Laura Weiss from The Resolution Center explored practical approaches drawn from mediation that can help individuals and organizations navigate disagreements more constructively. Their central message: resolving conflict requires moving beyond immediate reactions and positions to understand the underlying interests and needs of the people involved.


We share five strategies to help your nonprofit approach workplace conflict more effectively.

1. Recognize That Different Perspectives Drive Conflict


Conflict often arises when people have different perspectives on the same situation or when something they feel strongly about has been challenged. Like the people in the familiar parable of the blind men and the elephant, each person may see only part of the picture.


Recognizing that your perspective is not necessarily the whole story is an important first step. Rather than assuming someone is being difficult or unreasonable, consider that they may be responding to information, experiences, or expectations different from your own.


2. Choose Your Conflict Style Intentionally


Not every disagreement requires the same response. The Thomas-Kilmann conflict model identifies five approaches: avoiding, competing, accommodating, compromising, and collaborating. Each reflects a different balance between concern for the desired outcome and concern for the relationship.

Related Resources



Conflict Resolution Skills for the Workplace

Nonprofit Net of Greater Boston, Nov 10, 2026. (Video - 46 minutes)


Nonprofit Risk Management Center logo

What Nonprofits Need to Know About Conflict De-Escalation

Explore what conflict de-escalation is, how to practice it, and how to know when to seek additional help.

The Thomas-Killman Conflict Model

For example, avoiding may be appropriate when an issue is relatively unimportant, while competing may be necessary when an urgent decision must be made. Accommodating can help preserve an important relationship, and compromise may offer a practical short-term solution. However, when both the outcome and the relationship matter, collaboration is often the most productive approach.


The key is to recognize your default response and learn to adapt your approach to the situation rather than relying on a single conflict style.


3. Look Beyond Positions to Understand Interests


One of the most important concepts in mediation is the distinction between positions and interests. A position is what someone says they want; an interest is the underlying reason why they want it.


Consider the example of two sisters arguing over a single orange. One wants to make juice because she isn't feeling well, while the other needs the peel to make a cake for their grandmother. By asking questions about why each wants the orange, they discover that both can get what they need.


Workplace disagreements often have similar dynamics. Beneath an employee's stated position may be a need for recognition, fairness, respect, belonging, or safety. Understanding those underlying interests can reveal solutions that might not be apparent when everyone is focused on getting their own way.


4. Listen, Reflect, and Ask Open-Ended Questions


The presenters highlighted three essential practices for de-escalating conflict:


  • Listen: Give the other person your full attention. People are less likely to engage constructively when they don't feel heard.


  • Reflect: Repeat or summarize what you've heard to confirm your understanding and demonstrate that you've listened.


  • Ask: Use open-ended questions, particularly those beginning with "what" and "how," to uncover underlying concerns. Questions such as "Can you tell me more?" or "What's most important to you about this?" encourage people to explain their perspectives.


This process, sometimes called "looping" in mediation, helps people feel understood while creating opportunities to identify common interests and possible solutions.


5. Slow Down and Allow Time for Resolution


When conflict arises, the instinct is often to fix the problem quickly or react to what feels frustrating or unfair. However, stress can make it harder to think creatively and respond thoughtfully.


Taking a moment to pause, manage your own reactions, and ask questions can prevent a disagreement from escalating. It's also important to recognize that resolution may take more than one conversation. People need time to consider their perspectives, understand one another, and become willing to work toward a solution.


For supervisors and colleagues helping others navigate conflict, the goal is not necessarily to solve the problem for them, but to create space for a productive conversation.


Make Conflict Resolution a Workplace Skill


Conflict management is not just a skill for supervisors or human resources professionals. Everyone in a nonprofit contributes to its workplace culture. Developing the ability to listen, ask questions, recognize different perspectives, and look for common interests can help organizations address disagreements before they become more serious.


Start by reflecting on your own typical response to conflict and identifying one practice you can use in your next difficult conversation. Over time, these small changes can help build a more collaborative and respectful workplace.



Workplace Conflict Resolution Tips


Set the stage for better understanding when disagreements arise in your organization.


  • Create an environment where employees feel comfortable raising concerns and working through disagreements.

  • Recognize that people may have different perspectives on the same situation.

  • Consider the importance of both the desired outcome and the working relationship before choosing how to respond.

  • Try to understand the underlying needs and interests behind someone's stated position.

  • Listen without interrupting and reflect back what we've heard.

  • Use open-ended questions to encourage understanding rather than making assumptions.

  • Allow time for difficult conversations instead of rushing to a solution.



Comments


bottom of page